{ "study": "Five AI hotel implementations, Part II: consolidated Codex and Gemini analysis", "review_date": "2026-10-01", "review_status": "English and Portuguese Part II drafts consolidated with the supplied Gemini reports; claims reconciled against pinned repository evidence", "evidence": { "observed": "Local Git diffs, source review, fresh frontend suites/builds and isolated PostgreSQL SQL probes", "reported": "README implementation durations, cumulative token counters, backend tests, scanner results, Lighthouse and LOC", "inferred": "Maintenance implications and unexecuted browser/payment failure paths" }, "scope_limitations": [ "One reported feature session per codebase", "No audited generation logs, prompt iteration counts, repair counts or human review time", "Different feature semantics and quality-audit scopes", "Backend suites, fresh SonarCloud scans, Lighthouse, Kind deployments and full HTTP payment workflows were not rerun", "SQL probes exercise repository statements and schema objects rather than full application execution" ], "git_count_definitions": { "baseline": "Part I pinned source revision", "final_snapshot": "Local HEAD at review start, after feature and documentation commits", "excluding_readme": "Every tracked changed path except root README.md; includes source, tests, SQL, configuration and binary assets", "insertions_deletions": "Physical text lines from git diff --numstat; blank/comment lines included; binary files counted as files, without text line counts", "backend": "Paths beginning services/", "frontend": "Paths beginning web/ or frontend/" }, "rate_assumption": { "status": "Rates recorded in the project READMEs; arithmetic checked, current pricing not asserted", "uncached_input_per_million_usd": "0.10", "cached_input_per_million_usd": "0.01", "output_per_million_usd": "0.50", "formula": "((input-cached_input)*0.10+cached_input*0.01+output*0.50)/1000000", "accounting": "Cached input is a subset of input; reasoning is a subset of output; API-equivalent estimate, not a subscription invoice" }, "implementations": [ { "name": "Rust greenfield", "repository": "hotel-rust", "baseline": "961071eaa773c6f0e37c438da8336d2ac2f466eb", "feature_commit": "c747869746c8b321ce23d9180d80599c7447242b", "snapshot": "2bc09b8800faa4d7b8b3de4207279e24ad42e858", "feature_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 7, "created": 1, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 476, "deletions": 27, "net_lines": 449, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 7, "created": 1, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 476, "deletions": 27, "net_lines": 449, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 5, "created": 0, "modified": 5, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 87, "deletions": 22, "net_lines": 65, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 2, "created": 1, "modified": 1, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 389, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 384, "binary_files": 0 } }, "final_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 14, "created": 5, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 742, "deletions": 177, "net_lines": 565, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 13, "created": 5, "modified": 8, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 667, "deletions": 171, "net_lines": 496, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 11, "created": 4, "modified": 7, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 278, "deletions": 166, "net_lines": 112, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 2, "created": 1, "modified": 1, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 389, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 384, "binary_files": 0 } }, "readme_report": { "duration": "1h 13m 39s", "duration_seconds": 4419, "duration_basis": "README Worked for; not independently timed", "input": 20495593, "cached_input": 20061184, "output": 142242, "reasoning": 100798, "counter_cutoff": "2026-10-01 18:20 UTC, before final README editing and Git operations", "reported_changes": { "files": 14, "created": 5, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 740, "deletions": 177, "scope": "Analytics, performance work and README; feature alone 7 files, 476 insertions, 27 deletions" }, "reported_backend_tests": 34, "fresh_frontend_tests": 19, "reported_frontend_line_coverage_percent": 96.42, "lighthouse_report": "100 in five categories, desktop and mobile, Compose; includes performance pass", "uncached_input": 434409, "total_input_plus_output": 20637835, "recalculated_estimate_usd": "0.31517374", "cached_input_share_percent": 97.88, "quality_and_loc": { "backend_line_coverage": "All six packages reported passing cargo llvm-cov --fail-under-lines 80; reservation service SonarCloud coverage 96.5%", "sonar_open_issues": 0, "sonar_scope": "Seven separately analyzed projects; all seven quality gates reported passing", "loc": { "nonblank_source_configuration": 7306, "files": 61 } } }, "readme_source": "https://github.com/marcelomiyake/hotel-rust/blob/2bc09b8800faa4d7b8b3de4207279e24ad42e858/README.md", "fresh_frontend_checks": [ { "command": "npm test", "directory": "web", "exit_code": 0 }, { "command": "npm run build", "directory": "web", "exit_code": 0 } ] }, { "name": "Java architecture", "repository": "hotel-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs", "baseline": "47b0c3b79a96ba94c433e54639bfe9cdc5be1541", "feature_commit": "102392dd97e75b0896bd24aa78923c0158a292d5", "snapshot": "222ee5be2e5c09fac34ecb987b24cf3ec37e995b", "feature_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 26, "created": 15, "modified": 11, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 590, "deletions": 31, "net_lines": 559, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 25, "created": 15, "modified": 10, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 533, "deletions": 24, "net_lines": 509, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 10, "created": 4, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 248, "deletions": 24, "net_lines": 224, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 13, "created": 11, "modified": 2, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 283, "deletions": 0, "net_lines": 283, "binary_files": 0 } }, "final_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 26, "created": 15, "modified": 11, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 593, "deletions": 31, "net_lines": 562, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 25, "created": 15, "modified": 10, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 533, "deletions": 24, "net_lines": 509, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 10, "created": 4, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 248, "deletions": 24, "net_lines": 224, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 13, "created": 11, "modified": 2, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 283, "deletions": 0, "net_lines": 283, "binary_files": 0 } }, "readme_report": { "duration": "56m 5s", "duration_seconds": 3365, "duration_basis": "README Implementation time; not independently timed", "input": 19341292, "cached_input": 19002624, "output": 94710, "reasoning": 65429, "counter_cutoff": "README states final cumulative usage snapshot, not a sum of snapshots", "reported_changes": { "files": 26, "created": 15, "modified": 11, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 590, "deletions": 31, "scope": "Feature commit including README and configuration" }, "reported_backend_tests": 19, "fresh_frontend_tests": 33, "reported_frontend_line_coverage_percent": 87.82, "lighthouse_report": "100 in five categories on production frontend; form factor not specified in feature section; SEO META in 1 Click extension not opened", "uncached_input": 338668, "total_input_plus_output": 19436002, "recalculated_estimate_usd": "0.27124804", "cached_input_share_percent": 98.25, "quality_and_loc": { "backend_line_coverage": "Catalog 98.20%; reservation 97.92%, JaCoCo", "sonar_open_issues": 0, "sonar_overall_coverage_percent": 90.4, "loc": { "sonar_ncloc": 4083, "analyzed_files": 88, "reported_ncloc_delta": 221 } } }, "readme_source": "https://github.com/marcelomiyake/hotel-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs/blob/222ee5be2e5c09fac34ecb987b24cf3ec37e995b/README.md", "fresh_frontend_checks": [ { "command": "npm test", "directory": "web", "exit_code": 0 }, { "command": "npm run build", "directory": "web", "exit_code": 0 } ] }, { "name": "Java simple", "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni", "baseline": "2945cbb7fdd929d29ec1671654d6dd09486d15a0", "feature_commit": "bb441569663ed9378fe9d0edfd917a43a65e3e0b", "snapshot": "168f09b79cfb359f975ea4b2156c8a38bb125554", "feature_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 23, "created": 11, "modified": 12, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 807, "deletions": 393, "net_lines": 414, "binary_files": 3 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 22, "created": 11, "modified": 11, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 777, "deletions": 391, "net_lines": 386, "binary_files": 3 }, "frontend": { "files": 13, "created": 7, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 610, "deletions": 386, "net_lines": 224, "binary_files": 3 }, "backend": { "files": 9, "created": 4, "modified": 5, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 167, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 162, "binary_files": 0 } }, "final_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 23, "created": 11, "modified": 12, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 808, "deletions": 393, "net_lines": 415, "binary_files": 3 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 22, "created": 11, "modified": 11, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 777, "deletions": 391, "net_lines": 386, "binary_files": 3 }, "frontend": { "files": 13, "created": 7, "modified": 6, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 610, "deletions": 386, "net_lines": 224, "binary_files": 3 }, "backend": { "files": 9, "created": 4, "modified": 5, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 167, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 162, "binary_files": 0 } }, "readme_report": { "duration": "1h 6m 58s", "duration_seconds": 4018, "duration_basis": "README Worked for; not independently timed", "input": 26171295, "cached_input": 25815552, "output": 105900, "reasoning": 70136, "counter_cutoff": "README identifies one cumulative session log; no exact cutoff specified", "reported_changes": { "files": 23, "created": 11, "modified": 12, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 807, "deletions": 393, "binary_bytes_added": 153948, "scope": "Feature commit including README, staff extraction, responsive images and configuration" }, "reported_backend_tests": 20, "fresh_frontend_tests": 18, "reported_frontend_line_coverage_percent": 92.02, "lighthouse_report": "100 in four categories on mobile simulated audit", "uncached_input": 355743, "total_input_plus_output": 26277195, "recalculated_estimate_usd": "0.34667982", "cached_input_share_percent": 98.64, "quality_and_loc": { "backend_line_coverage": "85.01% combined JaCoCo", "sonar_open_issues": 0, "sonar_scope": "Final staged-code analysis; quality gate reported passing", "loc": { "production_nonblank": 3134, "production_files": 59, "test_nonblank": 888, "test_files": 12 } } }, "readme_source": "https://github.com/marcelomiyake/hotel-dry-kiss-yagni/blob/168f09b79cfb359f975ea4b2156c8a38bb125554/README.md", "fresh_frontend_checks": [ { "command": "npm test", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 }, { "command": "npm run build", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 } ] }, { "name": "Java refactored", "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs", "baseline": "429f97f28ffaa47ba208463fd11e555763a07b58", "feature_commit": "14f526207e66b77cc22b38831d49c86bb92f1f91", "snapshot": "14f526207e66b77cc22b38831d49c86bb92f1f91", "feature_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 19, "created": 9, "modified": 10, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 492, "deletions": 7, "net_lines": 485, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 18, "created": 9, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 440, "deletions": 4, "net_lines": 436, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 4, "created": 0, "modified": 4, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 50, "deletions": 4, "net_lines": 46, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 14, "created": 9, "modified": 5, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 390, "deletions": 0, "net_lines": 390, "binary_files": 0 } }, "final_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 19, "created": 9, "modified": 10, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 492, "deletions": 7, "net_lines": 485, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 18, "created": 9, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 440, "deletions": 4, "net_lines": 436, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 4, "created": 0, "modified": 4, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 50, "deletions": 4, "net_lines": 46, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 14, "created": 9, "modified": 5, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 390, "deletions": 0, "net_lines": 390, "binary_files": 0 } }, "readme_report": { "duration": "34m 40s", "duration_seconds": 2080, "duration_basis": "README explicitly calls this active work time provided for the task; not a verified common wall-clock measure", "input": 8056578, "cached_input": 7867648, "output": 58600, "reasoning": 39943, "counter_cutoff": "2026-10-01 16:07:48 UTC, latest cumulative thread usage cited by README", "reported_changes": { "files": 18, "created": 9, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 440, "deletions": 4, "scope": "Implementation and tests; excludes README" }, "reported_backend_tests": 28, "fresh_frontend_tests": 15, "reported_frontend_line_coverage_percent": 92.49, "lighthouse_report": "Not re-run for feature revision", "uncached_input": 188930, "total_input_plus_output": 8115178, "recalculated_estimate_usd": "0.12686948", "cached_input_share_percent": 97.65, "quality_and_loc": { "backend_line_coverage": "87.72% aggregate JaCoCo", "sonar_open_issues": 0, "sonar_overall_coverage_percent": 87.3, "sonar_new_code_coverage_percent": 89.4, "loc": { "production_nonblank": 3810, "production_files": 95, "test_nonblank": 1036, "test_files": 17, "production_scope": "Java, TypeScript, TSX and CSS" } } }, "readme_source": "https://github.com/marcelomiyake/hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs/blob/14f526207e66b77cc22b38831d49c86bb92f1f91/README.md", "fresh_frontend_checks": [ { "command": "npm test", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 }, { "command": "npm run build", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 } ] }, { "name": "Rust rebuilt", "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs-rermade-rust", "baseline": "fba23789a507bf3179a214560ee7f215ad9eaa74", "feature_commit": "64f22eeaf142265a7b1c592a25c084bf81d68c79", "snapshot": "9c1f8e7a37b9851a592fea34557d59e599c2fa0b", "feature_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 11, "created": 2, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 592, "deletions": 8, "net_lines": 584, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 10, "created": 2, "modified": 8, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 536, "deletions": 6, "net_lines": 530, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 4, "created": 0, "modified": 4, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 77, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 72, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 5, "created": 2, "modified": 3, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 458, "deletions": 1, "net_lines": 457, "binary_files": 0 } }, "final_diff": { "all_tracked": { "files": 11, "created": 2, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 593, "deletions": 8, "net_lines": 585, "binary_files": 0 }, "excluding_readme": { "files": 10, "created": 2, "modified": 8, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 536, "deletions": 6, "net_lines": 530, "binary_files": 0 }, "frontend": { "files": 4, "created": 0, "modified": 4, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 77, "deletions": 5, "net_lines": 72, "binary_files": 0 }, "backend": { "files": 5, "created": 2, "modified": 3, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 458, "deletions": 1, "net_lines": 457, "binary_files": 0 } }, "readme_report": { "duration": "44m 7s", "duration_seconds": 2647, "duration_basis": "README Task duration; not independently timed", "input": 15295531, "cached_input": 14891264, "output": 82074, "reasoning": 60303, "counter_cutoff": "2026-10-01 16:57:41 UTC, before final statistics README edit, follow-up commit, push and response", "reported_changes": { "files": 11, "created": 2, "modified": 9, "deleted": 0, "insertions": 592, "deletions": 8, "scope": "Feature commit including README and configuration" }, "reported_backend_tests": 15, "fresh_frontend_tests": 15, "reported_frontend_line_coverage_percent": 92.38, "lighthouse_report": "100 in four categories, desktop", "uncached_input": 404267, "total_input_plus_output": 15377605, "recalculated_estimate_usd": "0.23037634", "cached_input_share_percent": 97.36, "quality_and_loc": { "backend_line_coverage": "91.39% llvm-cov", "sonar_open_issues": 0, "sonar_overall_coverage_percent": 91.4, "sonar_new_code_coverage_percent": 92.2, "loc": { "feature_nonblank_insertions": 500, "feature_nonblank_deletions": 6, "feature_net_nonblank": 494, "scope": "Source and tests from staged diff; excludes README and configuration" } } }, "readme_source": "https://github.com/marcelomiyake/hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs-rermade-rust/blob/9c1f8e7a37b9851a592fea34557d59e599c2fa0b/README.md", "fresh_frontend_checks": [ { "command": "npm test", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 }, { "command": "npm run build", "directory": "frontend", "exit_code": 0 } ] } ], "sql_probe_run": { "command": "python3 /tmp/hotel-part2-probes.py", "environment": "New disposable postgres:17-alpine Docker container, no host ports or mounted application data; removed after probes", "outcome": "All 13 expected observation assertions matched across 42 recorded SQL steps", "initial_attempt": "Readiness check briefly observed the temporary initialization server; first psql connection failed. Re-ran with TCP readiness check; not classified as an application failure", "records": [ { "repository": "hotel-rust", "scope": "database SQL only", "schema_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/migrations/0002_reservation_journey_analytics.sql" ], "source_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/lib.rs" ], "steps": [ { "label": "start", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_journeys (journey_id, hotel_id, room_type_id, last_screen, status) VALUES ('53d0b2d8-3e50-495f-8642-e59303727172', 'ab1be6dc-bb5f-404a-8c25-e0c46b3705b0', 'c9ef1055-a6e8-4ef4-b6ba-87c5a679dfa5', 'guest_details', 'in_progress') ON CONFLICT (journey_id) DO NOTHING RETURNING journey_id", "observed": "53d0b2d8-3e50-495f-8642-e59303727172" }, { "label": "payment checkpoint", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_journeys SET last_screen = 'payment', last_activity_at = NOW() WHERE journey_id = '53d0b2d8-3e50-495f-8642-e59303727172'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "control inactivity", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_journeys SET last_activity_at=now()-interval '31 minutes';", "observed": "" }, { "label": "inactive view", "sql": "SELECT last_screen FROM abandoned_reservation_journeys;", "observed": "payment" }, { "label": "same-screen activity refresh", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_journeys SET last_screen = 'payment', last_activity_at = NOW() WHERE journey_id = '53d0b2d8-3e50-495f-8642-e59303727172'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "active view", "sql": "SELECT count(*) FROM abandoned_reservation_journeys;", "observed": "0" }, { "label": "later-arriving guest checkpoint", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_journeys SET last_screen = 'guest_details', last_activity_at = NOW() WHERE journey_id = '53d0b2d8-3e50-495f-8642-e59303727172'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "arrival order defines current screen", "sql": "SELECT last_screen FROM reservation_journeys;", "observed": "guest_details" } ] }, { "repository": "hotel-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs", "scope": "database SQL only", "schema_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/resources/db/migration/V2__record_reservation_funnel_events.sql" ], "source_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/java/com/wayfarer/reservation/adapter/out/postgres/JdbcReservationFunnelEventStore.java" ], "steps": [ { "label": "RESERVATION_STARTED", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_funnel_events\n (session_id, reservation_attempt_id, event_type, screen, hotel_id, room_type_id, occurred_at)\n VALUES ('832aee03-5533-4efc-a2be-81b35d5e2f8a', '4703593e-6f7f-423f-a73f-8e6bf7a24372', 'RESERVATION_STARTED', 'checkout', 'probe-hotel', 'probe-room', '2026-10-01T12:00:00Z')", "observed": "" }, { "label": "SCREEN_VIEWED", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_funnel_events\n (session_id, reservation_attempt_id, event_type, screen, hotel_id, room_type_id, occurred_at)\n VALUES ('832aee03-5533-4efc-a2be-81b35d5e2f8a', '4703593e-6f7f-423f-a73f-8e6bf7a24372', 'SCREEN_VIEWED', 'hotel', 'probe-hotel', 'probe-room', '2026-10-01T12:00:00Z')", "observed": "" }, { "label": "control inactivity", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_funnel_events SET occurred_at=now()-interval '31 minutes';", "observed": "" }, { "label": "last screen can be outside checkout", "sql": "SELECT last_screen FROM reservation_funnel_abandonments;", "observed": "hotel" }, { "label": "client confirmation without a booking table", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_funnel_events\n (session_id, reservation_attempt_id, event_type, screen, hotel_id, room_type_id, occurred_at)\n VALUES ('832aee03-5533-4efc-a2be-81b35d5e2f8a', '4703593e-6f7f-423f-a73f-8e6bf7a24372', 'RESERVATION_CONFIRMED', 'confirmation', 'probe-hotel', 'probe-room', '2026-10-01T12:00:00Z')", "observed": "" }, { "label": "confirmation removes abandonment", "sql": "SELECT count(*) FROM reservation_funnel_abandonments;", "observed": "0" } ] }, { "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni", "scope": "database SQL only", "schema_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/resources/schema.sql" ], "source_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/java/com/stays/reservation/ReservationJourneyRepository.java" ], "steps": [ { "label": "start", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_journeys (id, current_screen, status)\n VALUES ('fa039d9b-61b2-469b-9333-886f89eddfee', 'DETAILS', 'STARTED')\n ON CONFLICT (id) DO NOTHING", "observed": "" }, { "label": "checkout", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_journeys AS journey (id, current_screen, status)\n VALUES ('fa039d9b-61b2-469b-9333-886f89eddfee', 'CHECKOUT', 'STARTED')\n ON CONFLICT (id) DO UPDATE\n SET current_screen = EXCLUDED.current_screen, last_activity_at = now()\n WHERE journey.status = 'STARTED'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "control inactivity", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_journeys SET last_activity_at=now()-interval '31 minutes';", "observed": "" }, { "label": "no delivered leave event", "sql": "SELECT status FROM reservations.reservation_journeys;", "observed": "STARTED" }, { "label": "explicit leave event", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_journeys AS journey\n (id, current_screen, status, ended_at)\n VALUES ('fa039d9b-61b2-469b-9333-886f89eddfee', 'CHECKOUT', 'ABANDONED', now())\n ON CONFLICT (id) DO UPDATE\n SET current_screen = EXCLUDED.current_screen, status = 'ABANDONED',\n last_activity_at = now(), ended_at = now()\n WHERE journey.status = 'STARTED'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "late detail screen", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_journeys AS journey (id, current_screen, status)\n VALUES ('fa039d9b-61b2-469b-9333-886f89eddfee', 'DETAILS', 'STARTED')\n ON CONFLICT (id) DO UPDATE\n SET current_screen = EXCLUDED.current_screen, last_activity_at = now()\n WHERE journey.status = 'STARTED'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "abandonment is terminal for screen writes", "sql": "SELECT status||':'||current_screen FROM reservations.reservation_journeys;", "observed": "ABANDONED:CHECKOUT" }, { "label": "server paid completion", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_journeys\n (id, current_screen, status, started_at, last_activity_at, ended_at)\n VALUES ('fa039d9b-61b2-469b-9333-886f89eddfee', 'CHECKOUT', 'COMPLETED', now(), now(), now())\n ON CONFLICT (id) DO UPDATE\n SET current_screen = 'CHECKOUT', status = 'COMPLETED',\n last_activity_at = now(), ended_at = now()", "observed": "" }, { "label": "paid completion supersedes abandonment", "sql": "SELECT status FROM reservations.reservation_journeys;", "observed": "COMPLETED" } ] }, { "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs", "scope": "database SQL only", "schema_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/resources/schema.sql" ], "source_paths": [ "services/reservation-service/src/main/java/com/stays/reservation/adapter/out/jdbc/ReservationProgressRepository.java" ], "steps": [ { "label": "start", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions (session_id, status, last_screen, started_at, last_activity_at) VALUES ('6ec6142b-f97c-4d3f-9f41-f4b790bd390c', 'IN_PROGRESS', 'DETAILS', '2026-10-01T12:00:00Z', '2026-10-01T12:00:00Z') ON CONFLICT (session_id) DO NOTHING", "observed": "" }, { "label": "control inactivity", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions SET last_activity_at=now()-interval '31 minutes';", "observed": "" }, { "label": "sweep", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions SET status = 'ABANDONED', abandoned_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00' WHERE status = 'IN_PROGRESS' AND last_activity_at < '2026-10-01 19:07:41.440854+00' RETURNING session_id, last_screen", "observed": "6ec6142b-f97c-4d3f-9f41-f4b790bd390c|DETAILS" }, { "label": "later checkout screen", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions SET last_screen = 'CHECKOUT', last_activity_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00' WHERE session_id = '6ec6142b-f97c-4d3f-9f41-f4b790bd390c' AND status = 'IN_PROGRESS'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "later confirmation", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions SET status = 'COMPLETED', last_screen = 'CONFIRMATION', last_activity_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00', completed_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00' WHERE session_id = '6ec6142b-f97c-4d3f-9f41-f4b790bd390c' AND status = 'IN_PROGRESS'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "state remains abandoned", "sql": "SELECT status||':'||last_screen FROM reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions;", "observed": "ABANDONED:DETAILS" }, { "label": "fresh journey", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions (session_id, status, last_screen, started_at, last_activity_at) VALUES ('26828d7b-b4fe-4892-8f88-9d1e9bdfd5a5', 'IN_PROGRESS', 'DETAILS', '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00', '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00') ON CONFLICT (session_id) DO NOTHING", "observed": "" }, { "label": "confirmation needs no payment lookup", "sql": "UPDATE reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions SET status = 'COMPLETED', last_screen = 'CONFIRMATION', last_activity_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00', completed_at = '2026-10-01 19:37:41.385088+00' WHERE session_id = '26828d7b-b4fe-4892-8f88-9d1e9bdfd5a5' AND status = 'IN_PROGRESS'", "observed": "" }, { "label": "fresh outcome", "sql": "SELECT status FROM reservations.reservation_funnel_sessions WHERE session_id='26828d7b-b4fe-4892-8f88-9d1e9bdfd5a5';", "observed": "COMPLETED" } ] }, { "repository": "hotel-dry-kiss-yagni-refactored-ddd-cleanarch-cqrs-rermade-rust", "scope": "database SQL only", "schema_paths": [ "services/backend/schema/04_reservations.sql", "services/backend/schema/05_reservation_analytics.sql" ], "source_paths": [ "services/backend/src/journeys.rs" ], "steps": [ { "label": "start", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_analytics.journeys (journey_id,started_at,last_activity_at,last_screen,last_sequence) VALUES ('47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9',now(),now(),'details',1) ON CONFLICT (journey_id) DO UPDATE SET last_activity_at=now(),last_screen=EXCLUDED.last_screen, last_sequence=EXCLUDED.last_sequence WHERE reservation_analytics.journeys.completed_at IS NULL AND reservation_analytics.journeys.last_sequence < EXCLUDED.last_sequence RETURNING journey_id", "observed": "47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9" }, { "label": "newer checkpoint first", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_analytics.journeys SET last_activity_at=now(),last_screen='checkout',last_sequence=3, completed_at=CASE WHEN 'false' THEN now() ELSE completed_at END WHERE journey_id='47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9' AND completed_at IS NULL AND last_sequence < 3 RETURNING journey_id", "observed": "47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9" }, { "label": "older checkpoint later", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_analytics.journeys SET last_activity_at=now(),last_screen='details',last_sequence=2, completed_at=CASE WHEN 'false' THEN now() ELSE completed_at END WHERE journey_id='47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9' AND completed_at IS NULL AND last_sequence < 2 RETURNING journey_id", "observed": "" }, { "label": "control inactivity", "sql": "UPDATE reservation_analytics.journeys SET last_activity_at=now()-interval '31 minutes';", "observed": "" }, { "label": "ordered abandonment outcome", "sql": "SELECT status||':'||last_screen FROM reservation_analytics.journey_outcomes;", "observed": "ABANDONED:checkout" }, { "label": "paid booking without analytics completion write", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.bookings (id,hotel_id,room_type_id,hotel_name,city,district,image_path,image_alt,room_type_name,check_in,check_out,rooms,guests,guest_name,guest_email,total,status,payment_id) VALUES ('47e8429a-bf1b-4cd8-9ac7-5e32d262c3c9','e97962a0-1978-402a-8c38-f0e86f6a3a9b','2a3448d6-2b00-4607-9b55-38213e5c383e','Probe hotel','Probe city','Probe district','/probe.webp','Probe','Probe room',current_date+1,current_date+2,1,1,'Probe guest','probe@example.invalid',100,'CONFIRMED','d3e2abdc-e727-4877-a715-c5098c217689');", "observed": "" }, { "label": "payment-backed fallback", "sql": "SELECT status||':'||(completed_at IS NULL)::text FROM reservation_analytics.journey_outcomes JOIN reservation_analytics.journeys USING(journey_id);", "observed": "COMPLETED:true" }, { "label": "failed journey start", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservation_analytics.journeys (journey_id,started_at,last_activity_at,last_screen,last_sequence) VALUES ('48d60878-9b26-477b-9d44-11ae912fd5e6',now(),now(),'details',1) ON CONFLICT (journey_id) DO UPDATE SET last_activity_at=now(),last_screen=EXCLUDED.last_screen, last_sequence=EXCLUDED.last_sequence WHERE reservation_analytics.journeys.completed_at IS NULL AND reservation_analytics.journeys.last_sequence < EXCLUDED.last_sequence RETURNING journey_id", "observed": "48d60878-9b26-477b-9d44-11ae912fd5e6" }, { "label": "failed booking", "sql": "INSERT INTO reservations.bookings (id,hotel_id,room_type_id,hotel_name,city,district,image_path,image_alt,room_type_name,check_in,check_out,rooms,guests,guest_name,guest_email,total,status,payment_id) VALUES ('48d60878-9b26-477b-9d44-11ae912fd5e6','2588c07f-9edd-448a-8ca9-a7cd559458f2','2305927c-c819-41b2-b66e-2c1a741df51f','Probe hotel','Probe city','Probe district','/probe.webp','Probe','Probe room',current_date+1,current_date+2,1,1,'Probe guest','probe@example.invalid',100,'PAYMENT_FAILED',NULL);", "observed": "" }, { "label": "failed payment has distinct outcome", "sql": "SELECT status FROM reservation_analytics.journey_outcomes WHERE journey_id='48d60878-9b26-477b-9d44-11ae912fd5e6';", "observed": "PAYMENT_FAILED" } ] } ] }, "review_reconciliation": { "record": "maintenance-review-reconciliation.json", "source_reports": [ { "filename": "gemini-analysis.md", "sha256": "94d36231b529bed0f805a6a688d48c26121573d94108ca7944ca9dcb2e190ef6", "attribution": "Gemini reports supplied by the project owner" }, { "filename": "gemini-analysis-pt-BR.md", "sha256": "98ad0f0f5b073955809709e3db0408eb4b0da2a02c514c83012b2f2e785a886b", "attribution": "Gemini reports supplied by the project owner" } ], "independent_implementation_runs_added": 0, "earlier_observations_preserved": true } }